The Hemingway Trap
by ksbowner - November 9th, 2011So we have another storm brewing in romancelandia. A. J. Llewellyn writes m/m romance. Until very recently, she claimed to BE a gay man, even going so far as to hire a man to go to her book signings for her. Now that someone’s outed her, she’s claiming to be a transgender who identifies as a male. A lot of people are skeptical and I admit I’m one of them.
What amazes me is that she really thought she’d get away with this. I mean, come on, this is the age of the internet. All of our lives are a lot less private than they were say fifty years ago.
As to why she did, well I’m no psychiatrist but I do have my own theory. I think part of it may be that she fell into what I like to call the “Hemingway Trap”.
Ernest Hemingway created these ultimate macho men characters and then spent his life trying to convince himself and everyone that he was just as much of a he-man as his characters. But no one is ever as sexy, macho, desirable, brave (or whatever special quality you’d like to have) in real life as a FICTIONAL hero. In my opinion, his inability to keep up with his larger than life creations had something to do with his suicide.
I wonder if in her own way, Llewellyn was trying to BE her characters because they were special and she doesn’t feel she is??
Whatever her real motivation, it’s a big mess that didn’t have to be.
Sigh.


